I read a lot of really good books in 2024. For all that I'm one of those people who will read just about anything and who finds most stories enjoyable, I tend to be a fairly critical rater. I hate the inflationary system we've all been trained to participate in, where anything less than five stars means something is crap. My most common book rating is three stars. To me, three stars means "this book was entertaining and I liked it." It's not going to set the world on fire. It didn't blow my mind. But it was good. I enjoyed reading it and thought it was a nice way to spend my time. I don't regret the time I spent reading it even if maybe I won't remember the details of it in a few months.
Four stars is a great book. This is one I'm going to remember. I may have even highlighted a passage or two. Maybe I added a quote from it to my list on Goodreads. If it's part of a series, I'm going to finish that series. Four stars means this is an author I'm going to watch for future releases from and will also search out any previous works as well.
A five star book is one that blew my freaking mind. Five star books make me cry without making me feel the manipulation. They make me laugh out loud. They're books I want to start re-reading immediately after finishing. Five star books are ones I re-read endlessly and never weed out of my personal collection. They're the ones I recommend until my friends and family are so sick of hearing about them that they start avoiding book-talk with me. Five star books are books that stay with me and give me that dreaded-yet-wonderful book hangover.
I read 14 five star books last year. Each of them was special and wonderful and each of them will stick with me for a long time. There were two books though, that just absolutely floored me. One was so good it actually made me angry and you'll be hearing about that one in a couple of weeks. It's not out yet (I was lucky enough to score an advance copy), so I won't talk about it just yet, other than to say that Emily R. Austin is a genius and if you haven't read her yet, now is your chance to read through her back catalog before her newest book, We Could Be Rats, comes out.
The other 2024 book that stopped me in my tracks was Not Like Other Girls by Meredith Adamo. I first heard about it on BookTok - a book influencer was raving about the advance copy she'd gotten and I was intrigued. The description sounded fun, so I got on the list to listen to the audiobook through my local library and waited anxiously for it to arrive. I was expecting a fun little mystery - a girl goes missing, her former best friend investigates - the description gave off strong Veronica Mars vibes and I was into it. What I didn't realize until I started listening though is that Not Like Other Girls is actually so much more than what I was expecting. The mystery is maybe the least interesting, least important part of the book in a way.
Not Like Other Girls is a coming-of-age story in disguise. Jo-hyphen-Lunn, the main character, is lost and flailing her way through her senior year of high school. She's not like the other girls she knows and yet her story is likely to feel distressingly familiar to a lot of women. This was a book that literally had me in tears. Picture it: I've got a nice, easy workday ahead of me. All I need to focus on is some relatively mindless reporting to run and compile, meaning its a great day to pop in earbuds and listen to my fun, light, mystery novel I've been looking forward to. Cut to a few hours later and yep, there's me, shutting my office door so I can quietly cry in peace while Adamo rips my heart out and forces me to have a confrontation with my own fucked up girlhood.
True confession time - I've reached out to exactly two authors over the course of my reading life. The first was Zoje Stage. I did an eco-critical analysis of her fantastic book Wonderland as my final capstone project for my English degree and she was kind enough to consent to an email interview to give my paper a bit of star power. The second? Meredith Adamo to thank her for writing Not Like Other Girls (and trauma-dump a tiny bit). That's not me. I do not fangirl. I admire from afar. This book though? I had to reach out, connect.
I was a Jo-Lynn. A lot of us were, I think. We were the girls who were too awkward, who never quite felt like we fit in. Some of us were too loud, some too quiet. Some were too "slutty," whatever the hell that really means, some too prudish. We were the girls who got told we were "so mature for our age" and that, yeah, we weren't like other girls. We were special. We'd always felt different anyway because of that outcast awkwardness that we didn't know everyone was experiencing to some extent in high school, so when we were told that we were different, special, we ate it up with a spoon and asked for more. We were the girls who were prey. Adamo gives all of us a voice in Jo-Lynn with this absolutely stunning debut novel that I cannot recommend enough. I loved it so much that the day after I finished the audiobook, I ran out and bought it in hardcover so I can re-read it whenever I want.
Check out Not Like Other Girls. It's good, I promise.